Skip to main content

Should the SF Giants have pulled the trigger on a Bryce Miller trade with Mariners?

He would have fit into the Giants rotation nicely.
ByMichael Swinehart
Sep 2, 2026; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Seattle Mariners pitcher Bryce Miller (50) throws a pitch against the Boston Red Sox in the first third at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: David Butler II-Imagn Images
Sep 2, 2026; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Seattle Mariners pitcher Bryce Miller (50) throws a pitch against the Boston Red Sox in the first third at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: David Butler II-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The hot stove is heating up as the upcoming lockout looms over our heads like a stormcloud. Potential rotation target Sonny Gray signed with the Twins on Wednesday, and the Royals and Mariners matched up for the most notable trade of the offseason so far. In a six-player deal, Gold Glove third baseman Maikel Garcia headed northwest to Seattle with starter Bryce Miller being the primary return piece heading back to KC.

Before acquiring Garcia, Seattle was known to be scouring the trade market for different infield options, such as Ketel Marte and our own Casey Schmitt. The Giants and Mariners would have lined up well on paper for a trade, considering they're apparently dangling Schmitt to other teams in the hopes of filling out a rotation in desperate need of reinforcements. Trader Jerry now says there's "zero chance" that the Mariners will part with another pitcher in exchange for offense after the deal for Garcia was announced.

Would Bryce Miller have been the right target, and is Casey Schmitt the right piece to dangle?

It's obviously too late now, but if the Mariners had offered a similar package to what they sent to Kansas City in exchange for a package headlining Schmitt, should the Giants have pulled the trigger? Schmitt isn't the defender Garcia is, nor does he have the same on-base chops, but he certainly hits for more power and comes at a more affordable price, as he's yet to even hit arbitration yet. Garcia is controllable through 2031 on a five-year, $57.5 million extension with a club option for 2031 that he signed last year - team-friendly for most clubs considering his talent level, but a bit of an impedance for a team like the Mariners who tend to spend pretty frugally.

The Mariners, for their part, probably found Garcia a more attractive target than Schmitt despite Schmitt having the aforementioned edge on power and affordability. For one thing, Garcia has had a considerably more decorated career so far than the late-blooming Schmitt despite being a year younger, as he's somehow still only 26 despite being around the league for parts of five seasons now.

Garcia's 10.5 career WAR dwarfs Schmitt's 1.8, and aside from just having played in many more career games (531 vs. 323), defensive contributions are the biggest reasons for that. Garcia has been worth 38 OAA (outs above average) over his career per Baseball Savant, compared to -7 for Schmitt. Schmitt has been marked as average to slightly above at his natural position of third base, and below-average everywhere else he's been asked to play - particularly left field, where he hasn't looked particularly comfortable. Chapman's presence does complicate Schmitt's fit on the roster, even though he's at least a serviceable option at the keystone as well.

For Schmitt to bring back a package comparable to what the Royals received, the Giants would presumably have to part with an additional asset or two. Miller looked like a budding star in his age-25 2024 season, pitching to a 2.94 ERA in 180.1 innings, before suffering through two up-and-down seasons following that. The Royals are banking on him getting back to his previous self, and considering the cost of pitching these days, it's a worthwhile risk for a still-young arm with multiple years of control remaining.

Of course, Schmitt alone would probably be able to net a controllable starter with slightly less pedigree than that of Miller, and there are several trade partners out there who might still line up well. The Marlins could use some lineup help and have quite a few young arms, and the Yankees - a frequent trade partner of late - are known to be seeking an upgrade at the hot corner.

The Giants may also hold onto Schmitt if they don't find a deal to their liking, as controllable power bats don't grow on trees, and end up addressing the pitching staff via free agency. Normally we'd have the whole offseason to wait and see what they do, but since teams may want to get a good portion of their business done before the December 1st lockout, we may not have to wait that long after all.

Add us as a preferred source on Google