A big trade was made yesterday between the Royals and Mariners involving Maikel Garcia. Naturally, there’s been speculation that the SF Giants might choose to trade Casey Schmitt for pitching after Jeff Passan of ESPN reported that was something they’ve been thinking about.
There are pros and cons to trading Schmitt. Those in favor might argue that San Francisco’s need for pitching is so great that it’s warranted. Plus, there are red flags that suggest Schmitt’s 2026 may not be sustainable like his incredibly low walk rate.
Opponents would argue that the versatility Schmitt provides is invaluable and that his power potential of 30 homers is too great to give up on. He’s also young enough that he could potentially be a contributor the next time the team is competitive even if 2027 ends up being more of a gap year.
It seems obvious that the Giants shouldn’t just give Schmitt away. They need to get a return that is worth it so let’s look at three trades that would make sense from San Francisco’s perspective.
3 Casey Schmitt trades that give Giants a good return
Pittsburgh Pirates
The Pirates could use an upgrade at third base and Schmitt has proven that’s his best defensive position. What about a trade that sent Schmitt, Trent Harris, and Jacob Bresnahan to Pittsburgh in exchange for right-handed pitcher, Luke Weaver and right-handed pitcher Braxton Ashcraft?
Weaver would give San Francisco a closer for the 2027 season and Ashcraft would be a really good young starter to add to the rotation after he made the NL All-Star team in 2026. Giving up Harris and Bresnahan might sweeten the deal enough for the Pirates to bite.
New York Yankees
The Yankees feel like an obvious fit given their need for a third baseman and the fact they were reportedly in on Garcia before he was dealt to Seattle. Maybe a deal that sends Schmitt to New York in exchange for Ryan Weathers, Ben Hess, and Luis Gil would get the job done.
Weathers is a lefty who had a 3.60 ERA in 25 starts last season and Gil was moved to the bullpen last season after struggling but he showed promise earlier in his career as a starter. Hess is the No. 5 ranked prospect in New York’s system and is a promising young right-handed arm.
Seattle Mariners
While it might seem like the Mariners no longer have a need for Schmitt after the Garcia trade, they could stick him in the outfield or move him around the diamond. What about a deal that sent Schmitt and reliever Dylan Smith to Seattle for right-handed starter Emerson Hancock and closer Andres Munoz?
Hancock had a 3.57 ERA in 25 starts in 2026 and Munoz had a bit of a down year after two straight All-Star campaigns but he still recorded 28 saves. Smith would at least give the Mariners another solid bullpen arm.
We will see if the Giants do try to trade Schmitt, but if they do it had better be for a good haul otherwise they may come to regret dealing him away especially if he goes on to be an All-Star for another team.
