Skip to main content

SF Giants' Casey Schmitt may be next domino to fall after Royals-Mariners Maikel Garcia trade

This might open the floodgates.
ByNick San Miguel
San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants third baseman Casey Schmitt (10) before the game against the Colorado Rockies at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Darren Yamashita-Imagn Images
San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants third baseman Casey Schmitt (10) before the game against the Colorado Rockies at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Darren Yamashita-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

While it was a little unclear just how active teams would be on the trade front with the lockout looming, the Kansas City Royals and Seattle Mariners showed that at least some teams are willing to make a deal with Kansas City trading infielder Maikel Garcia to the Mariners in exchange for several pitchers including starter Bryce Miller. Could SF Giants utility man Casey Schmitt be the next player dealt?

The reason why Schmitt could follow is because on Wednesday morning, Jeff Passan of ESPN wrote an article breaking down what he’s been hearing around MLB and included one passage towards the bottom of the piece: “Kansas City and San Francisco, both desperate to upgrade their rotations, have floated infielders Maikel Garcia and Casey Schmitt for pitching help.”

This doesn’t really come as a shock because this whole offseason I’ve grappled with the idea of trading Schmitt in exchange for pitching. The Mariners seemed like an obvious trade partner to me but now that they acquired Garcia they may not be willing to trade for Schmitt although they could decide to stick him in the outfield as a replacement for Randy Arozarena who seems likely to depart in free agency.

Still, for any teams with a surplus of pitching and a need for a third baseman or utility man who proved that he has 30-home run potential, Schmitt might become a very hot commodity in the coming weeks.

Giants-Yankees trade involving Casey Schmitt still feels like a possibility

One team to keep an eye on is the New York Yankees. They could use an upgrade at third given the struggles of Ryan McMahon and could also use a new second baseman with Jazz Chisholm Jr. likely to depart in free agency. They also have several pitchers they’d likely be open to trading in Clarke Schmidt, Ryan Weathers, and Will Warren.

While the Giants certainly shouldn’t be eager to trade Schmitt away, what if they were able to get one of those three starters and then were also able to land a prospect like Carlos Lagrange in the deal? That might be worth it from San Francisco’s perspective as they look to build up a pitching staff that sorely needs more talent.

Of course, trading Schmitt would be a risk since he proved last year just how good he can be offensively and how versatile he is on defense. The big red flag is his low on base percentage and lack of walks so if the Giants think he might be due to regress then this may be the right time to trade him when his value is at its highest.

A Schmitt trade is far from a certainty, but the fact that Garcia was traded shortly after Passan said it was a possibility leads one to believe that Schmitt could be next if the Giants get a good offer. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google