Skip to main content

SF Giants should be dangling Matt Chapman over Casey Schmitt as trade chip in pitching pursuit

The only problem is teams may not want him.
ByNick San Miguel
San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants third baseman Matt Chapman (left) and second baseman Casey Schmitt (right) walk on the field before the game against the Colorado Rockies at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Darren Yamashita-Imagn Images
San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants third baseman Matt Chapman (left) and second baseman Casey Schmitt (right) walk on the field before the game against the Colorado Rockies at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Darren Yamashita-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The biggest rumor flying around the SF Giants right now is that they are open to trading Casey Schmitt in order to get pitching per Jeff Passan of ESPN. This took on even greater relevance after the Kansas City Royals traded Maikel Garcia to the Seattle Mariners to get pitching in return. Garcia was another name Passan had floated as a trade candidate alongside Schmitt.

We will see if the right deal comes along and the Giants do end up trading Schmitt, but they should probably be thinking about trading Matt Chapman instead. The only problem is that Schmitt is coming off a very good year, is younger, and is far cheaper which is why teams will be more interested in him than Chapman, but Mark Feinsand of MLB.com even speculated that Chapman could be a trade candidate.

On the other hand, Chapman is coming off a bad, injury-plagued season, is still owed over $100 million, and has a full no-trade clause so he can veto any deal. That’s what makes it so hard to deal him but in a perfect world San Francisco could trade him and make Schmitt their third baseman going forward.

It’s just tough to see a lot of teams jumping at the chance to take Chapman’s contract on. He’s 33 years old and only played in 84 games last season and 128 games the year prior due to injury. He hit just .235/.324/.368 with seven home runs and 42 runs batted in.

Teams may still want Matt Chapman for his defense

Chapman still provides elite defense at third so a team might be willing to overlook some of the offensive warning signs because of that, but there’s still the issue of Chapman getting to veto any trade.

Past reporting has suggested that Chapman wants to remain on the West Coast because that’s where his family is which makes a trade to the East Coast unlikely. That’s unfortunate because the New York Yankees make all the sense in the world as a trade partner given their need for a third baseman and San Francisco’s need for pitching. 

A Chapman trade is not impossible, but a Schmitt trade is just simpler from San Francisco’s perspective. He can’t veto it, he’s a more attractive player, and he could probably get a bigger haul than Chapman.

Still, the Giants should dangle Chapman in addition to Schmitt as they look to upgrade a pitching staff that could certainly use some more talented arms because if they can hang onto Schmitt he might be a much more valuable player than Chapman going forward. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google