Teams all around MLB are making roster moves to clean up their rosters ahead of the deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players as they also decide which prospects to protect from the Rule 5 Draft and make room for free agent signings. Former SF Giants catcher Joey Bart was designated for assignment by the Chicago White Sox on Tuesday to make room for recently signed Dustin May per Robert Murray of FanSided.
Bart is entering his last season of arbitration eligibility and MLB Trade Rumors projects that he is set to earn roughly $2.9 million which is on the expensive side for a catcher who has not been able to stick as a starter. Yet, the Giants could use more depth at the catcher position since they currently have a young crop of catchers in Daniel Susac, Drew Cavanaugh, and Jesus Rodriguez.
Bart was with three different teams in 2026, the Pittsburgh Pirates, Atlanta Braves, and Chicago White Sox. He hit a collective .214/.305/.357 with four home runs and 13 runs batted in. 2024 and 2025 with the Pirates were better seasons but he has just not been able to grab hold of a regular role with any team.
He was once seen as the heir apparent to Buster Posey at catcher so it would be a little bit ironic if Posey decided to bring him back into the fold several years after the Giants gave up on him because they were so confident that Patrick Bailey was the future at catcher.
Clearly, Posey eventually came to believe that Bailey was not the future any longer and was willing to roll the dice on their younger options by trading him. The Giants should be open to adding a veteran catcher or two into the mix so the the team is not solely relying on such young options. They're probably thinking of less expensive options than Bart, though.
Giants should explore other veteran catcher options
The Giants would have to clear a 40-man roster spot for him and they’d have to be comfortable with paying him close to $3 million when they could bring in a couple veteran catchers on minor league contracts next year for a fraction of the cost and they’d probably be superior options to Bart.
That’s why the Giants should resist any temptation to claim Bart. We saw Posey decide to claim Camilo Doval at the end of the season and now they are faced with a tough decision on whether to non-tender him. Claiming Bart would just add another tough choice to the equation.
It would certainly be an interesting move, but there are cheaper options out there who would likely be as good as, or better than, Bart so there’s no need to take another chance on him given the likely price tag.
