Skip to main content

Dustin May's hefty White Sox deal is bad news for SF Giants in starter pursuit

None of these guys are going to come cheap.
ByNick San Miguel
Milwaukee, WI, USA;  Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) speaks during a workout session before the 2026 World Series.  Mandatory Credit: Benny Sieu-Imagn Images
Milwaukee, WI, USA; Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Dustin May (21) speaks during a workout session before the 2026 World Series. Mandatory Credit: Benny Sieu-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The SF Giants were one of many teams recently mentioned as having interest in free agent starter Dustin May. They did not end up signing him as May has reportedly inked a three-year, $52.5 million deal with the Chicago White Sox which was a much more expensive contract than many anticipated he would get. Now the mid-tier starting pitching market has been reset for San Francisco.

That’s not a good thing because it has seemed pretty clear both based on common sense and comments made by president of baseball operations Buster Posey that the Giants will probably not be going after one of the big fish pitchers in free agency.

Tarik Skubal is obviously the big fish and the Giants clearly won't make a run at him, but even guys like Freddy Peralta, Sonny Gray, and Michael King feel like they will be out of a price range San Francisco is comfortable with.

Well, the Giants had better be ready to pay more than they anticipated if they want to meaningfully upgrade the rotation because if May gets a deal worth $17.5 million per year, that means a lot of other pitchers are going to have his contract to point to as evidence for why they deserve more money.

May had a 4.70 ERA last season with the St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers. That does not tell the full story as his FIP on the year was 3.63 and Eno Sarris of The Athletic detailed how some of his underlying numbers and advanced metrics suggest he was better than his ERA implies, but still, that contract is going to provide fodder for agents around MLB who want more money for their clients.

Giants are going to have to pony up a bit to land a starting pitcher

Think that Kevin Gausman can be had for cheap? He had a 4.51 ERA last season with a 3.74 FIP so he’s at least going to make $20 million per year on whatever contract he signs, if not closer to $25 million per year. The same applies to all of those mid-tier free agents who will also now feel emboldened to ask for a three-year deal rather than a two-year deal.

May is a little younger at the age of 29 so that is a key difference, but his contract is definitely going to be used by other pitchers with similar stats as an argument for why they deserve more money.

The Giants probably wouldn’t have agreed to a contract with May at the price Chicago paid so they likely don’t feel as if they missed out, but this contract could have some pretty big ramifications the rest of the offseason as they look to sign at least one, and more likely two starters.

Add us as a preferred source on Google