The deadline to protect eligible prospects is later today. The SF Giants have several candidates to consider, including Blake Holub, Marty Gair, and Henry LaLane.
No one knows if the Rule 5 draft will actually take place this offseason. While the deadline to protect eligible players is before the expiration of the current Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA), the actual draft normally takes place during the winter meetings. If both sides cannot agree to a new deal by December 1, then baseball will enter a lockout.
Three prospects the SF Giants ought to consider protecting from the Rule 5 draft
During last cycle's negotiations, teams agreed to table the Rule 5 draft. That may be the same outome this time around, but teams will likely operate as if it will happen. One note I should mention is that the minor league phase should continue as planned.
1. Blake Holub
One of the Giants' newest prospects is also one that they will need to decide on right away. They acquired Blake Holub and Gavin Perry in a deal that sent Ryan Walker to the Milwaukee Brewers.
Presumably, the Brewers were not planning to protect Holub, so they traded him instead of watching another team possibly select him in the Rule 5 draft.
Holub will be one of the more experienced pitchers in the Rule 5 draft. Oftentimes, teams are selecting prospects who have not played extensively above Double-A. That is not the case for Holub, as he has spent parts of the past three seasons at Triple-A.
The right-handed pitcher is coming off a strong 2026 campaign, posting a 2.10 ERA with 66 strikeouts and 22 walks in 55.2 innings for the Nashville Sounds. He throws from an extremely high delivery, and leans on a cutter-slider mix. The slider sits in the mid 80's and gets two-plate movement, while the cutter averages over 95 MPH. Relievers with success in Triple-A tend to be in demand through this channel.
2. Marty Gair
The Rule 5 draft is often an exercise in risk management. Teams will protect players based on the chances of losing that player if left unprotected.
Rarely are there well-round players in the Rule 5 draft. Those players typically get protected, so teams will target trais and Gair offers some intriguing traits that would interest a lot of terms.
The hard-throwing righty is relatively light on pro experience. Despite being drafted in the 13th round of the 2023 draft, he only has 75 innings to his ledger. In a small sample, Gair has boasted some intriguing strikeout totals, along with very high walk rates. Across two minor seasons, he has tallied a 4.68 ERA, 1.49 WHIP, 14.9 K/9, and a 1.97 SO/W rate.
The below-average control will limit him to a bullpen role, but that can still work if there is improvement. Gair flashes an upper 90's fastball with late carry up in the zone that he pairs with a mid 80's slider and an upper 80's changeup. Teams would gladly take a chance on pure stuff alone, hoping that they can get him to throw a few more strikes.
3. Henry LaLane
Speaking of green with experience, Henry LaLane has appeared in six minor league seasons while completing just 242.2 innings. 99.2 of those innings took place in 2026, as he split time between the New York Yankees and the Giants.
LaLane came over to San Francisco in the deal that sent Heliot Ramos to New York. The southpaw pitcher posted a 3.16 ERA, 1.07 WHIP, 10.3 K/9, and a 3.35 SO/W rate across 21 outings, including eight appearances in High-A to finish the year.
On the mound, LaLane gets plenty of extension from his 6-foot-7 frame and can land his fastball in the zone for strikes. He does not have quite the same feel for his changeup and slider. The four-seamer sits in the mid 90's after picking up a couple of ticks on it last offseason.
The Giants plan to continue stretching LaLane out as a starter, leading to a longer development curve. If the Giants protect him, it might take some time before he is ready to help out the club. Of course, another team might try to accelerate his development by picking him in the Rule 5 draft and converting him to a reliever.
