Skip to main content

MLB insider’s update on SF Giants’ Casey Schmitt trade stance is a major relief

A trade is far from a certainty.
ByNick San Miguel
San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants infielder Casey Schmitt (10) reacts after striking out to end the inning against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the seventh inning at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Robert Edwards-Imagn Images
San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants infielder Casey Schmitt (10) reacts after striking out to end the inning against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the seventh inning at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Robert Edwards-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The last few days have been dominated by Casey Schmitt trade speculation for SF Giants fans. Ever since Jeff Passan reported that San Francisco is open to the idea of trading Schmitt for pitching there have been a lot of trade ideas thrown out there, but it does not seem like the Giants are desperate to get rid of Schmitt.

MLB insider Robert Murray of FanSided gave an update on the Schmitt trade chatter and wrote the following: “But one source emphasized that San Francisco is not shopping Schmitt, noting that teams see he and Matt Chapman on the same roster and are inquiring about Schmitt.”

That is a very important distinction to make. It wouldn’t be logical if the Giants were actively trying to get rid of Schmitt. Maybe there’s some world in which they see his incredibly low walk rate and decide that he is almost certainly going to decline going forward so they might as well get something for him while his value is at its peak.

Yet, the fact that he was on pace for 30 homers when he injured his knee is reason enough to keep him around even if he’s never going to have a .400 OBP. It makes sense to at least be open to trading Schmitt so long as the return is adequate.

Trading him just to get rid of him doesn’t really make sense especially since he was one of the team's better players last season. The Giants have two open holes at second base and in left field. Schmitt has proven the last two seasons that he can fill the void at both of those spots if needed and he’s young enough at 27 where he could conceivably still be a key part of the team the next time it is a contender.

Giants would be unwise to force a Casey Schmitt trade

In a perfect world the Giants would probably like to trade Matt Chapman since he’s older and more expensive which would open third base up for Schmitt, his natural position where he’s made some insane plays when given the opportunity. But obviously Chapman’s no-trade clause complicates that.

The Giants are probably better off getting their pitching through free agency unless a trade just makes too much sense. While a pitcher like Will Warren of the New York Yankees is intriguing, it’s not like he’s a slam dunk acquisition. At best he’s probably a No. 3 starter and Schmitt could have easily been an All-Star last season so it certainly feels like Schmitt has the higher ceiling even if San Francisco has a greater need on the pitching side. 

Trading for Warren would almost feel like trading for another Landen Roupp. A solid arm, but not necessarily worth giving up a good player in order to get him. That’s why Murray’s update is a positive one. The Giants aren’t dead set on trading Schmitt but they’re open to it if the deal is right which is the exact right way to approach things.

Add us as a preferred source on Google