The SF Giants got rid of a few players who have become familiar to fans the last few years in the past week. San Francisco traded reliever Ryan Walker to the Milwaukee Brewers in exchange for two pitchers last week and then DFA’d infielder Christian Koss before trading him to the Tampa Bay Rays in exchange for a hard-throwing pitcher.
While both of these decisions are completely justifiable based on performance in 2026 as Walker had an ugly 7.16 ERA while Koss hit a paltry .217/.257/.305 in over 200 plate appearances, one can’t shake the feeling that the Giants might end up looking kind of silly for letting them go.
They ended up going to two teams that are notorious for milking the most talent out of players. The Brewers and Rays faced off in the 2026 World Series which is notable because neither of them have extremely high payrolls and the way they are able to consistently be good is by finding talent at the margins rather than signing a bunch of big free agents the way the New York Yankees and Los Angeles Dodgers typically operate.
Both Rays and Brewers are known for getting the most out of their players
If any team can turn Walker back into the nearly un-hittable version of himself that he was back in 2024, it’s Milwaukee. We saw in 2026 how they were able to take Kyle Harrison, a pitcher San Francisco was never able to get the most out of, and turn him into an elite arm in the first half of the season before injuries derailed him.
As for the Rays, they don’t really have any stars on their team other than Junior Caminero. A lot of their lineup consists of guys they either drafted or scooped up from other teams and turned into solid players. Richie Palacios is a good example of a guy who didn’t do much with the St. Louis Cardinals but the Rays got him and now he’s a respectable second baseman.
It wouldn’t shock anyone if Koss ends up being solid for the Rays going forward. It’s also sort of fitting that he ended up there since the Giants player he is most reminiscent of is Matt Duffy and San Francisco ended up trading Duffy to Tampa Bay as well.
Even if Walker and Koss do go on to have success with Milwaukee and Tampa Bay respectively, it doesn’t necessarily mean the Giants were wrong to move on from them. Walker needed a fresh start somewhere and the Giants have Marcelo Mayer who should fill the role Koss played the last two seasons.
Still, it always stings a bit when a player who was with the Giants goes on to do well with another team so if Walker and Koss do good things for the Brewers and Rays there might be a tinge of regret for letting them go.
