While Sonny Gray always seemed like a potential fit for the SF Giants given the fact he once pitched for the A’s, he has repeatedly chosen the Midwest or East Coast in free agency and that trend continues as he signed a two-year, $55 million with the Minnesota Twins with a player option after the first season.
It’s a nice reunion for Gray who spent 2022 and 2023 with Minnesota, earning an All-Star nod in his second year there. Gray is 37 years old and coming off a very strong season with the Boston Red Sox and his deal could provide a template for the Giants if they seek to reunite with Kevin Gausman.
Like Gray with the Twins, Gausman spent two years in San Francisco, 2020 and 2021, and was an All-Star in his second season. The Giants unfortunately did not bring him back in free agency and he went on to be very solid for years with the Toronto Blue Jays.
Now San Francisco has a chance to right that wrong by signing him after he had a 4.51 ERA in 32 starts last season between Toronto and the Chicago Cubs. One might thing the Giants could get him at a discount since he is almost 36 and coming off a bit of a down year, but the fact that Dustin May just got a sizable contract and Gray also got a nice pay day suggests Gausman is not going to come cheap.
Giants are going to have to be aggressive if they want Kevin Gausman
He probably won’t get $55 million like Gray, but I would not be surprised at all if he gets a two-year contract in the $45-50 million range. Keep in mind that MLB teams are not just looking at ERA when deciding who to sign. May earned his three-year, $52.5 million deal thanks to his FIP which suggested he got a bit unlucky and advanced stats like Stuff+.
Gausman’s FIP was 3.74 which suggests some bad luck and teams also seem to be prioritizing pitchers who have a really good changeup or splitter after seeing successful teams like the Tampa Bay Rays succeed with that approach. Anyone who watched Gausman with the Giants will remember how effective his splitter was.
A two-year deal makes a ton of sense for Gausman and the Giants. He would provide some rotation stability for a couple years and can act as a bit of a bridge until some of the younger arms in the farm system like Jackson Flora are ready to make their big league debut.
Starting pitchers do not come very cheap these days though so at the very least the Giants will probably have to give Gausman in the neighborhood of $22 million per year to convince him to come back to the Bay Area. My prediction earlier this offseason was that the Giants would give him two years for $50 million because they might have to outbid other interested teams like the Toronto Blue Jays who could also want to reunite with Gausman.
The Gray signing sort of sets the parameters for what a Gausman contract could look like though since they are both veteran pitchers, so now we shall see if the Giants want to bring him back.
