The SF Giants could potentially have a lot of Hall of Fame inductees at Cooperstown next year and the headliner should be catcher Buster Posey. While Giants fans mostly agree that he should obviously be a slam dunk first-ballot Hall of Famer, I am not sold that he will be.
Don’t get me wrong, I one hundred percent believe that he should be a first-ballot Hall of Famer. He has the stats even if his career was not especially long, he won Rookie of the Year and the NL MVP after a catastrophic injury, and he won three World Series titles which perhaps not so coincidentally occurred within five years after he got called up in 2010.
That is a Hall of Fame pedigree, but it’s important to keep in mind who is voting on who makes it into the Hall of Fame: the Baseball Writers’ Association of America. Posey will need 75-percent of the vote to make it in. Do we really think 75-percent of these writers view Posey the same way that Giants fans do?
Absolutely not. Many of them wouldn’t have thought about Posey at all had he chosen a quiet retirement out in Georgia. Many would look at his numbers and probably conclude that he didn’t play long enough and didn’t have the requisite longevity.
Now enter the fact that he has had a very decidedly non-quiet retirement. He became a minority owner of the Giants took over as San Francisco’s president of baseball operations less than three years after his final game as a player and things have not gone especially well.
It will not be a smooth path on the first ballot for Buster Posey
For most of the writers voting, the headlines they’re either read or written about Posey in the last year have not been especially flattering. While one would hope these voters will be able to keep separate Posey the player and Posey the executive, I don’t have particularly high hopes.
Bob Nightengale of USA Today was president of the BBWAA last year and asked Justin Verlander back during the All-Star break if he thinks Posey’s tenure as an executive should have any impact on his Hall of Fame case. Verlander shot the question down and clearly thought it was a ludicrous notion, but if that line of questioning is at all representative of the way other voters are thinking about Posey’s case then it could spell trouble.
As of right now, I still think Posey will make it in on the first ballot. The fact that it’s a fairly weak class coupled with Joe Mauer’s induction a few years ago should be enough to get him across the finish line, but I expect it to be really close. Mayer got 76-percent of the vote and I think Posey will probably be in that 75-80 percent range if he does make it.
He should be a shoe-in, but this is the same body that didn’t make Derek Jeter a unanimous first-ballot Hall of Famer so I wouldn’t put anything past it.
