Skip to main content

Next 2 moves SF Giants should make to fix bullpen after retaining Camilo Doval

Time to add some new arms.
ByNick San Miguel
Phoenix, Arizona, USA;  San Francisco Giants pitcher Camilo Doval (75) celebrates  after beating the Arizona Diamondbacks in the tenth inning at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Matt Kartozian-Imagn Images
Phoenix, Arizona, USA; San Francisco Giants pitcher Camilo Doval (75) celebrates after beating the Arizona Diamondbacks in the tenth inning at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Matt Kartozian-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The big question today for the SF Giants was what they were going to do with reliever Camilo Doval. They could have non-tendered him as today was the deadline, but per Ken Rosenthal and Andrew Baggarly of The Athletic, San Francisco has signed him to a one-year, $6.3 million deal.

That’s a little less than the $6.6 million projection made by MLB Trade Rumors, but it feels pretty fair for a guy who was once an All-Star and is only a season and a half removed from being a pretty solid reliever.

The Giants know the risks involved as they’ve also seen Doval at his lowest like in 2024 when he got demoted to Triple-A, but this move is the first real step made to reconstruct the bullpen for 2027.

It’s not a bad idea to look to the first half of 2025 as a model for the last time the Giants had a really good bullpen. Doval was back to pitching like his usual self and Randy Rodríguez was nearly unhittable. Both of them will be back next year and while it would be unrealistic to expect them to produce exactly the way they did, especially with Rodríguez coming off Tommy John, that’s at least a better start than what they entered last season with.

Ryan Walker is no longer in the fold which is a positive and per Alex Pavlovic of NBC Sports Bay Area, the Giants view Doval and Rodríguez as their setup men while they still seek a closer for the ninth inning.

Giants still need to make two more signings to fix bullpen

If they can sign a closer and a left-handed reliever, then they should feel pretty good about things going into next season. For closer, Kenley Jansen and Raisel Iglesias make the most sense as free agent options just given their experience at closing games. Trades for someone like Trevor Megill are also a possibility but San Francisco shouldn't give up too much.

They also need to sign a left-handed reliever. JoJo Romero and Steven Okert both make a lot of sense but they need somebody to fill the void left by Erik Miller as a late-innings lefty who can come into high-leverage situations.

If you add one of each, then you are looking at a bullpen that has has an experienced closer, Doval and Rodríguez as setup guys, Sam Hentges as a low-leverage lefty and and whoever they sign as their high-leverage lefty, and then a competition for the last three spots which could end up going to guys like Dylan Smith, Trent Harris, and Anthony Molina who all showed promise last season.

It’s not the “Core Four” era of the bullpen, but it’s a start and would at least give the bullpen much more order compared to last season. Keeping Doval around helps set some of that vision into motion but now the Giants have to be proactive and sign some guys to ensure the bullpen is in a better place. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google