Today is going to be a hectic day around MLB as the non-tender deadline is at 2 PM PST. This means that every team has to make a decision on whether to tender a contract to, or non-tender, all of their arbitration eligible players. The SF Giants have four players who fall under this category: Casey Schmitt, Sam Hentges, Randy Rodríguez, and Camilo Doval who will be the biggest question mark while the other three are pretty obviously going to be tendered a contract.
Doval is projected to earn a $6.6 million deal in arbitration according to MLB Trade Rumors. That is based on his past results, but the Giants would probably chafe at paying that much given how much Doval struggled the last year and a half.
President of baseball operations Buster Posey said the team is still talking through what the best course of action with Doval is, but they have a few choices. They can non-tender him which would immediately make him a free agent, they can tender him a contract and then either figure out a contract later or go to arbitration, or they could potentially announce they’ve agreed on a one-year deal.
That second option may be the most likely as Andrew Baggarly of The Athletic recently speculated that the two sides might agree on a compromise contract that isn’t quite as high as that $6.6 million number. Maybe a contract closer to $5 million would make the Giants more comfortable.
At the end of the regular season it definitely seemed like Doval was happy to be back with the Giants. He was smiling a lot and said it felt good to be back. The results on the mound backed up those good feelings as he had two nearly flawless outings against the Los Angeles Dodgers in the last series of the year.
Giants know just how good Camilo Doval can be when he is right
The Giants have seen Doval at his best and his worst so they know what the roller coaster looks like. While it may be a bit of a risk to bring him back, the last time the Giants had a good bullpen they had Doval and Rodríguez at the back end of it so it’s hard not to long for a return to that even though it’s a question whether either of them can get back to their form in the first half of 2025.
Obviously, they shouldn’t just tender Doval a contract and call it a day when it comes to the bullpen but if they bring him back, sign a legitimate closer like Kenley Jansen or Raisel Iglesias, and sign a solid left-handed reliever then the bullpen will look a lot stronger on paper than it did going into 2026.
We will see what San Francisco decides to do, but I expect them to keep Doval in the fold even if his deal may end up being a bit on the pricey side.
