Skip to main content

Mariners say they're done trading starters, but SF Giants should try to make them change their mind

They can try to put together an attractive trade package.
ByNick San Miguel
Seattle, Washington, USA; Seattle Mariners starting pitcher Logan Gilbert (36) pitches to the San Francisco Giants during the sixth inning at T-Mobile Park. Mandatory Credit: Steven Bisig-Imagn Images
Seattle, Washington, USA; Seattle Mariners starting pitcher Logan Gilbert (36) pitches to the San Francisco Giants during the sixth inning at T-Mobile Park. Mandatory Credit: Steven Bisig-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

One might think the Seattle Mariners aren’t open for business after trading for third baseman Maikel Garcia in a six-player deal with the Kansas City Royals on Wednesday. It may be harder to swing a trade now, but the SF Giants can still try to make a run at one of their pitchers.

It will not be easy as Mariners president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto said that there is “zero” chance the team trades from its starting pitcher depth after trading Bryce Miller to the Royals.

Maybe he sincerely means that or maybe it’s just a bargaining play, but Dipoto also told the media that Seattle is in the market for a right-handed bat which means Casey Schmitt could remain on the table as a potential trade option. Jung Hoo Lee could also make sense for Seattle.

It would be nice if San Francisco could snag one of Seattle’s starters in a trade. Logan Gilbert is the best of the bunch but he’s only under contract through the 2027 season so it would be a bit risky to trade for him when next season is so uncertain.

There are other options like George Kirby, Bryan Woo, and Emerson Hancock who are under team control for two, three, and four years respectively. Acquiring a pitcher like that would be perfect for a Giants rotation that needs to fill two open slots.

Giants can make an aggressive offer to mariners

Is Schmitt an attractive enough trade chip to get Seattle to back off its reluctance to trade another starter? For a Mariners team that struggled offensively last season, adding a versatile player like Schmitt who can play both the infield and outfield and probably would have hit 30 home runs had he not gotten hurt last season might just be worth it.

The Giants are not reported to be open to trading Lee the same way they are Schmitt, but he could be attractive to a team like Seattle. His contact approach could provide a little more stability to that offense but Lee’s contract, and his popularity amongst Giants fans, make him hard to trade. Maybe the Giants could package Schmitt and Lee to try to get Seattle to bite.

What if the Mariners really won’t budge on their starters? Could San Francisco turn to someone like closer Andrés Muñoz? He’s coming off a tough year with a 4.24 ERA while converting only 28 of 38 save opportunities, but he was an All-Star in 2024 and 2025.

Maybe the Giants could get him in exchange for Schmitt even if it might be risky to get a closer who is only under contract through 2027. That’s a lot to give up for one year of a closer especially if next season is shortened due to the lockout.

That’s why the Giants should really only trade Schmitt or Lee to Seattle if they can get a starter who is under team control for several years in return. Unless the Mariners budge on that then there really isn’t any point in making a deal for a closer who would probably only be with the team for a year. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google