Even an MLB insider is questioning the SF Giants' handling of Bryce Eldridge

The SF Giants have received some backlash from the fanbase for their handling of power-hitting prospect Bryce Eldridge since being called up. Now, MLB insider Bob Nightengale of USA Today is even questioning it, calling it a "head-scratcher."

Yes, I know. It is Nightengale. Even a clock is right twice a day, but this highlights how Eldridge's handling is being viewed from the outside.

The Giants called up the left-handed bat at the beginning of May to inject some life into an inconsistent offense. However, there is just one problem with this. Eldridge has not seen consistent playing time since the promotion.

The three-game series against the A's over the weekend was another example of that. He appeared in just one game, collecting three hitless at-bats in a 5-2 loss.

The SF Giants do not have a clear path to playing time of Eldridge

Even when the Giants called up Eldridge, they did not have a clear path to playing time for the 21-year-old prospect. He is limited defensively, with the ability to play first base and DH. However, the Giants have coverage at those positions. Casey Schmitt and Rafael Devers have split time at those spots this season.

Schmitt has been the club's best hitter, so his bat needs to be in the lineup every day. It is questionable whenever he is not in the lineup because it means that the underperforming veterans are getting the nod instead. That is a roster dynamic that Tony Vitello has to navigate.

Schmitt has experience all around infield, but if he sees time on the left side of the infield, it usually means that one of Willy Adames or Matt Chapman are on the bench. The Giants do not like the optics of pursuing that approach. So, Schmitt has seen the bulk of his time at either first base or DH this season.

It does not leave many at-bats for Eldridge. Not surprisingly, it has been tough for the left-handed bat to find a rhythm. He has just two hits, including a home run, with three walks and nine strikeouts in 27 plate appearances this season. On a positive note, Eldridge did launch his first home run, but it has been difficult to get it going otherwise.

It does pose the question of why even him Eldridge on the roster in the first place? I suppose he will benefit from working with the major league coaching staff, but for a player of his age, consistent game reps are crucial to his development.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow