Will Buster Posey's Hall of Fame case be hurt by brutal tenure as Giants executive?

While SF Giants fans understandably consider Buster Posey a lock for the Hall of Fame, it’s not up to fans. It’s up to the Baseball Writers’ Association of America and for many of those baseball writers the last time they’ve thought about Posey has been in a negative light.

Things aren't exactly going all that well for the Giants and more and more people are starting to blame Posey for that. Whatever vision he had for the team is not panning out as intended and the Giants are currently one of the worst teams in baseball.

Posey got some credit for jumping back into the fray as an executive after he retired as a player. He could've just enjoyed retirement and been forever remembered as the guy who helped lead the Giants to three World Series titles. The fact that the Giants handed Posey the keys despite him having no executive experience showed just how desperate the team was to try to get back on track or at least win fans back after the mediocrity of the Farhan Zaidi era.

But since he’s taken over the product on the field has actually gotten worse, not better. The Giants started off strong in 2025 but basically after the Rafael Devers trade, Posey’s signature move as president of baseball operations, the team has fallen off a cliff.

His other big decisions, signing Willy Adames to a huge deal and firing Bob Melvin and replacing him with Tony Vitello as manager, haven’t panned out all that well either which is why national baseball writers are beginning to view Posey as one of the executives around MLB who is facing the most scrutiny. His handling of the recent Pride Night controversy and touchiness about the team’s bullpen have also been a bad look for a guy who pretty much no one could say a cross word about as a player.

Posey should be a lock for HOF but it's not that simple

Should Posey the executive impact how writers think about Posey the player? No. But human beings aren’t robots and they’re going to vote with everything that person has done in mind, especially whatever they have done recently. Barry Bonds is not in the Hall of Fame because he took steroids but it’s also because he was not exactly chummy with the media and those writers remembered that.

Baseball writers are a sensitive breed and while Posey never rubbed the media the wrong way when he was a player you can bet that some voters are going to be influenced by how things have gone during his tenure in the front office. It’s not fair and it’s stupid but it’s going to happen.

Will that prevent Posey from being elected to the Hall? That’s unclear. He needs to get 75% of the vote on the ballot to be elected. For better or worse, a lot of voters are going to compare Posey to Joe Mauer who was elected with 76.1% of the vote on the first ballot in 2024. Yet, some are going to hold it against Posey that he only played 12 big league seasons and injuries limited his production in some of his later years.

Combine that with the fact that there are some who will want to stick it to him for thinking he could run a big league front office without any experience and it’s not hard to see a scenario in which Posey doesn’t clear the 75% threshold. 

The one thing working in Posey's favor is that it is not an especially stacked ballot as other first-timers include players like Jon Lester, Jay Bruce, and Brett Gardner so that fact alone may help Posey out quite a bit.

He should still be elected someday no matter what, but there’s at least a chance he won’t be a first-ballot Hall of Famer given how things have gone as an executive. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow