Buster Posey hinted to Alex Pavlovic of NBC Sports Bay Area that the SF Giants will not seriously consider players who have received a qualifying offer. If that holds true, then you can cross Trevor Rogers, David Bednar, and Adrián Morejón off the list.
Posey highlighted the importance of the picks in needing to build the farm system. The next Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) could change the penalty for signing a player who rejected a qualifying offer. Currently, the penalty for the Giants would be the loss of their second-highest pick in the 2027 draft and $500,000 in international bonus pool money during the 2028-2029 signing cycle.
When the Giants signed Jeff Samardzija in 2015, they forfeited their first-round pick in the 2016 draft. After that, they went nearly 10 years without signing players who had received a qualifying offer. Then, within the same calendar year, the Giants added Matt Chapman, Blake Snell, and Willy Adames, all of whom received and rejected a qualifying offer.
The penalty is a small price to pay if a team is in the competitive window and is one or two players away from positioning itself to advance further. However, that may not make a lot of sense for a team that just won 65 games.
SF Giants can still find quality bullpen options outside of Adrián Morejón and David Bednar
The Giants need pitching. A lot of it. They especially need high-leverage bullpen arms. Adrián Morejón and David Bednar are some of the best relievers in baseball. Adding either would check an important box for the Giants.
However, adding a reliever of that caliber may not make sense if a team is not seriously considering competing next season. It might be a pleasant surprise if the Giants did, but Buster Posey's latest admission does highlight that there will be some restraint in how they approach the offseason.
Outside of the qualifying offer, Morejón and Bednar expect to receive lucrative, multi-year deals. The Giants have not spent at that level for a reliever since they signed Mark Melancon to a four-year, $62 million in 2016. That trend will likely continue this year.
The front office plans to address the bullpen, and there are plenty of quality relievers available who do not have a qualifying offer tied to their name.
The same holds for Trevor Rogers. He expects to land a sizable payday, and the Baltimore Orioles have issued him a qualifying offer. While he may be one of the best pitchers available, he has rarely handled a high workload, surpassing the 150-inning threshold just once in his seven-year career.
