In dire need of starting pitching, the SF Giants will be without a young, promising arm for most or all of next season. Trevor McDonald, 25, underwent Tommy John surgery on August 5 and is expected to return only in late 2027 or 2028. McDonald was one of four young Giants starters to undergo the procedure. Blade Tidwell, Hayden Birdsong, and Carson Whisenhunt are the other three.
In his first meaningful stint in the major leagues, McDonald had shown enough to at least earn consideration for a spot in the rotation next season. He came into the year having pitched just 18 innings at the major-league level – three in 2024 and 15 in September 2025.
From an intriguing opening stretch to months of rehab
Hunting for a larger role, McDonald had an up-and-down spring before being optioned to Sacramento on March 23 – he posted a 1.80 ERA across his first four Cactus League appearances (10 innings) but gave up seven earned runs in 1 2/3 innings over his final two appearances.
His first opportunity of the season came as a spot starter. McDonald was called up on May 4, threw seven innings of one-run ball with eight strikeouts and no walks on just 81 pitches against the Padres, picked up the win, and was optioned back the next day to make room for reliever Joel Peguero. A more sustained opportunity presented itself less than a week later.
With Logan Webb sidelined by right knee bursitis, McDonald returned to the rotation on May 9. After two solid starts against the Dodgers and A's, his ERA stood at 2.37. His first poor outing of the season – the White Sox tagged him for seven earned runs on May 22 – marked the start of a rocky stretch for the young pitcher.
McDonald went 0-4 and posted a 5.73 ERA in five June starts. Two major issues started to emerge: length and control. McDonald failed to pitch through the third inning twice in June and never made it out of the fifth. Plus, he walked three batters in four of his five outings. The inconsistency became even more apparent in July.
His first start of July was one of his best of the season: a six-inning one-hitter against the Diamondbacks in which he struck out five hitters and didn't walk any. In his next start, at home against the Blue Jays, McDonald couldn't make it out of the second inning, as Toronto collected 11 hits and scored eight runs off him. Five days later, he held the Rockies to just three knocks and one run over seven innings.
In his last July start against the Royals, which would turn out to be his last of the season, McDonald pitched four innings and allowed three runs. As he was warming up for the fifth, he felt discomfort in his elbow. The Giants placed him on the injured list the following day. After further evaluation and a second opinion, McDonald underwent Tommy John surgery on August 5.
His final numbers – a 3-7 record and 5.12 ERA across 14 starts – don't jump off the page. With his May 22 and July 7 outings removed – when he allowed a combined 15 runs against the White Sox and Blue Jays – his ERA drops to 3.50 over his other 12 starts. His 4.30 FIP suggests a more productive year than his 5.12 ERA indicates – but still not the kind of year expected of an established, reliable starter.
Lefties presented a much greater problem to McDonald. They batted .288 with an .846 OPS against him and accounted for six of the seven home runs he surrendered. As for righties, they hit just .212 with a .558 OPS against McDonald.
McDonald was reinstated from the 60-day injured list to the 40-man roster on November 2 as part of the roster housekeeping. The expectation is that McDonald should return in 2028, though a late-2027 return isn't completely off the table yet.
