The return the SF Giants got in the Tyler Mahle trade was, at least on paper, the least appealing of the five trades they completed at the deadline. A 24-year-old righty with limited experience and underwhelming results at the major-league level was who they received in exchange for a veteran who had struggled for most of the season.
Molina entered the 2026 season with 52 games at the major-league level under his belt. He appeared in 35 with the Colorado Rockies in 2024 and posted a 6.79 ERA. He made just 17 appearances the next season while posting a 7.27 ERA. The Atlanta Braves claimed him from Colorado in December 2025 and immediately outrighted him to their Triple-A team.
Molina made a few appearances in spring training with the Braves and pitched a couple of innings for his country – Venezuela – at the World Baseball Classic before spending most of his season in the minors. Atlanta called him up three times this season but used him in just three games – Molina posted a 5.40 ERA over those three appearances (five innings). His numbers in Triple-A were encouraging: 18 games, nine starts, 3.64 ERA, one save. He was traded to the Giants on August 2.
Now three and a half months removed from the trade, Molina has shown enough in his limited time with the Giants to be considered a legitimate in-house option for next season's rotation.
From a dismissed return package to a rotation option
Molina's first three starts in the Giants' organization came with the River Cats. He posted a 3.00 ERA over nine innings and was called up on August 24. The circumstances behind his first opportunity with the major-league club were unusual. Molina, who was reportedly making coffee, got unexpectedly called into action to replace Adrian Houser, who had to leave the game early with an injury. Fifty-two pitches later, Molina had held the Cincinnati Reds scoreless for 4 1/3 innings, given up just one hit, and picked up the win in the process.
His first actual scheduled start came against his former Braves teammates on August 31. Molina earned his second straight victory, allowing three runs over five innings. In his third start with the Giants, he allowed just one hit and struck out six Mets batters. He did give up two runs, but neither was earned.
Of the 12 earned runs Molina gave up with the Giants this season, more than half of them came against the Padres on September 11, as San Diego collected nine hits and scored seven runs off Molina. Outside that outing, Molina allowed just five earned runs over 26 innings – a 1.73 ERA.
A reliever for the bigger part of his major-league career – he made just two starts in 2024 and 2025 combined – Molina started five games for the Giants and pitched at least three innings in each of his six outings. He threw at least five innings four times and made it through the sixth once, in his last start of the season against the Twins, his only quality start of the year. Despite that effort, Molina was tagged with the loss.
It's still too early to decide who between the Braves and Giants won the trade. Mahle gave Atlanta really productive innings in the postseason, while the Giants got a young, controllable pitcher who appears ready to contribute at the major-league level as soon as next season.
The Giants can go several ways with Molina next season. He could be a surprising addition to their starting rotation, as Buster Posey named him along with Cesar Perdomo and Yunior Marte as in-house options. He could provide bulk innings or long relief. Or the Giants could still option him back to Sacramento, as Molina still has one remaining option.
