While the Boston Red Sox probably don’t completely regret trading Rafael Devers to the SF Giants in June of 2025 since they have made the playoffs each of the last two seasons, it’s been obvious to all that they’ve had a tough time replacing him. They traded for Willson Contreras last year to try to add more production at first base and now they have overpaid free agent first baseman Jake Bauers to try and give themselves another power-hitting left-handed first baseman.
Bauers is coming off a career year with the Milwaukee Brewers. He hit .266/.389/.484 with 26 home runs and 86 runs batted in and was a huge part of Milwaukee’s playoff run which resulted in the franchise’s first World Series title.
The Brewers extended Bauers a qualifying offer but he probably realized this would be his best chance to earn a long-term deal so it’s not a surprise he said yes to Boston’s offer of four years for $58 million.
That’s a pretty hefty sum to pay for a guy who is 31 years old and has hit .211/.307/.365 in his career if you take out his 2026 numbers. Maybe he’s found something and will continue to be the guy he was in 2026, but there’s also a chance that last season was an aberration and the Red Sox will feel foolish giving him that contract.
Rafael Devers showed Red Sox what they are missing in 2026
Meanwhile, Devers proved in 2026 that his days of being a dangerous bat are not behind him. April gave Giants fans a scare, but once he got going he was one of the better hitters in the game. He finished the year hitting .258/.340/.525 with 37 home runs and 98 runs batted in.
He is a NL Silver Slugger Award nominee along with Bauers so they both had seasons that could be deserving of an award, but going forward it seems pretty obvious that Devers has more upside.
Devers is a year younger than Bauers and he obviously has a much more impressive track record. While he is still owed a ton of money and his contract may not age very well in the 2030s, he should still be a productive hitter the next few seasons.
Boston seems to be betting that having Bauers and Contreras as their options at first base and designated hitter will be a good combo and maybe they’re right, but the fact that the Red Sox had to overpay for a left-handed first baseman shows they are still trying to replace the void left by Devers.
