Ranking the 4 frontline starters the SF Giants should target in free agency

As the MLB offseason officially gets underway the SF Giants' path toward a pennant feels as daunting as ever. The NL West is always a gauntlet. However, next season, the Giants must contend with the NL Champion Diamondbacks, the ever-looming, powerhouse Dodgers, and a retooling Padres club still flushed with premiere talent. The way they can do that is buy adding a frontline starter.

Ranking the 4 frontline starters the SF Giants should target in free agency

San Fransisco has several notable needs to address before Opening Day 2024. Near the very top of this list is a need for a top-tier starting pitcher. While the club was able to piece together a respectable starting rotation, the unit was noticeably void of star talent outside of ace Logan Webb.

While veteran Alex Cobb performed well in limited action, starters Ross Stripling, Sean Manaea (who has opted out), and Anthony DeSclafani all struggled to find their footing. The team was able to mask some of these issues. However, a front-line starter to pair with Webb would give the franchise a major boost.

Unfortunately, superstar target Shohei Ohtani's recent elbow surgery is expected to keep him from pitching in 2024. While he should 100% remain the top priority for the Giants this offseason, both as a hitter in 2024 and as a two-way phenom in 2025, we will not include him on this list.

Thankfully there are a number of other superstar arms on the free-agent market this offseason. Which make the most sense for the SF Giants? Let's discuss!

Ranking the 4 frontline starters the SF Giants should target in free agency

4) Sonny Gray

Gray is a different caliber ace than the others on this list. He was superb in 2023, establishing himself as an AL Cy Young finalist, pitching to the tune of a 2.79 ERA, and earning his third career All-Star honors.

Gray's 11-year MLB career has been something of a roller coaster. At times, he has been one of the best pitchers on planet Earth. At others, he has failed to separate himself from the blob of average starting pitchers.

The Twins' star would certainly slot into the #2 spot (behind incumbent star Logan Webb), in the Giants' rotation. While this would be a dangerous duo, Gray does fall closer to the line of bonafide ace than one would prefer.

He should not be the Giants' best offseason target. However, landing him in addition to another All-Star would be a major boost to the club as they seek to compete for the NL West crown. At a projected annual market value of just over $20 million per season, he is a sensible target for the SF Giants.

Ranking the 4 frontline starters the SF Giants should target in free agency

2) Aaron Nola

The career Phillies star is entering free agency with a strange 2023 profile. The former All-Star was inconsistent, to the tune of a 4.46 ERA in 32 outings. Oddly, Nola has alternated between stellar seasons and disappointing ones nearly every year of his career. If this eight-year trend has any predictive value, the ace may be poised for to improve in 2024.

However, Nola flashed his top-tier upside in the postseason. He shut out the rival Miami Marlins over seven innings of work, earned a victory against the NL leading Braves in the NLDS, and went 1-1 with a 3.48 ERA against the eventual NL Champion Diamondbacks.

The Giants' pitching rotation has performed well with a collection of journeymen and veterans in recent years. However, adding a player with Nola's pedigree would give San Fransisco the type of co-ace to pair with Logan Webb.

The Giants would have to pay major money to pluck Nola away from Philadelphia. In fact, it would likely take at least $24.5 million per year on a multiyear contract to bring him to Oracle Park. He would be the clear top pitching target if it weren't for...

Ranking the 4 frontline starters the SF Giants should target in free agency

1) Blake Snell

Speaking of hot and cold, we bring you, Blake Snell! On one hand, Snell is a former Cy Young winner (2018) who is the odds-on favorite to claim the prestigious award again in 2023. At his best, he is a top-tier pitcher with the ability to dominate games.

The former Rays and Padres ace enters free agency on the heels of a stellar 2023 campaign. In a world full of home runs and inflated offense, Snell led the majors with a dazzling 2.25 ERA, while striking out 234 batters, and winning 14 games.

This type of dominance is nothing new for the veteran pitcher, who holds a career ERA of 3.20. It's not hyperbole to suggest that, if signed, Snell could potentially enter the hallowed grounds occupied by former franchise icons like Madison Bumgarner, Matt Cain, and Tim Lincecum.

Incumbent ace Logan Webb, a Cy Young finalist in his own right, has been amazing at the top of the rotation. The notion of him and Snell together should give fans flashbacks of the Lincecum/Cain one-two punch.

However, there are concerns in Snell's game that must be considered. First amongst these is his control issues.

In the midst of his standout season, the San Diego star also led all of baseball with 99 walked batters. For context, Braves veteran Charlie Morton held the second-highest mark in MLB... With just 76 walks.

If indeed Snell does capture his second Cy Young honors, he would be the first player since Early Winn in 1959 to capture the award while pacing the league in walks. While this did not stop him from dominating his competition, it is something that Giants President Farhan Zaidi and his front office must consider.

Additionally, Snell carries a small level of season-to-season consistency concern. For instance, since 2018, Snell has had two seasons with a 2.25 ERA or lower. During that same span, he has two seasons with an ERA over 4.20. While the veteran's ceiling is high enough too high to pass up, the Giants should be prepared for an occasional low floor.

Snell's $23.4 million per season projected market value is a huge commitment. However, San Fransisco has been in the market to spend big money on a superstar for several off-seasons. adding the ace would provide the Giants with a to-of-the-rotation starter while also stealing him for an NL West rival.