3 SF Giants players who will not be back in 2023
The SF Giants are slumping to the finish line after dropping four straight games while falling to fourth place in the NL West with a 65-73 record. This season has undoubtedly been disappointing and changes are coming. Several players will not returning next season including three that might surprise many fans.
3 SF Giants players who will not be back in 2023
The Giants will need to turn it around quickly as this front office might be on the hot seat if the struggles continue next season. Giants fans will forever remember the 107-win season in 2021, but it feels like they are pretty far away from their next postseason appearance.
The front office will be tasked with righting the ship and that will begin by making some tough decisions.
1. First baseman Brandon Belt
This might be the toughest move given what Brandon Belt has meant to the organization since he was selected in the fifth round of 2009 draft out of the University of Texas in Austin, Texas. He has been an above-average contributor on offense while turning into one of the best hitters in baseball in recent seasons. Plus, he has offered a steady glove at first base.
That said, this has been Belt's toughest season. The longtime Giants first baseman underwent season-ending surgery on his right knee, which is an ailment that has bothered him for years. It was clear that he was not fully healthy as he was not able to drive the ball like he has in the past.
In 298 plate appearances, the left-handed bat has slashed .213/.326/.350 (91 OPS+) with eight home runs, 23 RBI, and 25 runs. This includes a 12.4 percent walk rate against a 27.2 percent strikeout rate. The ability to take a walk has never been an issue, but the knee injury sapped Belt of his power as these are the worst numbers of his career.
Hopefully, the 12-year veteran is able to make it back to the baseball field. More importantly, the hope is that he can enjoy his post-playing career without any mobility issues.
With all that being said, it might be time for the Giants to turn the page on Belt. The veteran first baseman will be a free agent in the offseason and will likely need to prove that he is healthy enough to play before he receives any serious interest.
The Giants can fill the void at first base by re-signing Wilmer Flores or targeting a player like Josh Bell, but they have enough coverage as currently constructed with J.D. Davis, David Villar, and LaMonte Wade Jr. all under team control for 2023.
3 SF Giants players who will not be back in 2023
2. Middle infielder Tommy La Stella
The SF Giants signed Tommy La Stella to a three-year, $18.75 million pact prior to the 2021 season with the hope that he could give them leverage against right-handed pitching but that idea just has not come to fruition.
The 33-year-old infielder battled a hamstring strain in 2021 and recovered slowly from offseason Achilles surgery last year. It is clear that he is not fully healthy as he has only tallied 76 total innings in the infield in 2022.
The results in the batter's box have not been much better. In total, La Stella has slashed .244/.295/.380 (85 wRC+) with just nine home runs in 433 plate appearances with the Giants. This includes a 6.5 percent walk rate against a 12.7 percent strikeout rate.
The Giants had hoped that La Stella would be a better on-base threat, but the walk rates above 10 percent that he posted earlier in his career has not carried over since signing with San Francisco.
Plus, he has posted an 89 wRC+ against right-handed pitching over the last two seasons, so it is tough to envision a role for him going forward. On top of that, he has accumulated just five plate appearances in nine September games as the Giants look at players who might be able to help them next season.
Susan Slusser of the San Francisco Chronicle noted La Stella's diminishing playing time recently as an indicator that a change of scenery might be needed for both parties. La Stella is aware of the situation, but he has not yet heard anything from the Giants about next season.
3 SF Giants players who will not be back in 2023
3. Left-handed pitcher Carlos Rodón
In the case of Brandon Belt and Tommy La Stella, it is possible that they will not be back with the SF Giants next season due to performance. That is not the case at all with Carlos Rodón.
Rodón has been fantastic since inking a two-year, $44 million pact with the Giants prior to this season. However, his contract includes an opt-out clause if he reaches 110 innings pitched in 2022, which he did earlier in the season.
This is an easy call for the left-handed hurler to exercise his opt-out clause as he has been fantastic in a Giants uniform. In 28 starts, Rodón has registered a 2.93 ERA, 2.33 FIP, 1.05 WHIP, 11.7 K/9, and a 4.42 SO/W ratio while earning a NL All-Star bid. He will likely set a franchise record as his 11.7 K/9 will surpass the previous record set by Kevin Gausman (10.6 K/9) last season.
Speaking of Gausman, the former Giants hurler signed a five-year, $110 million pact with the Toronto Blue Jays in the offseason. Those terms will serve as a starting point for what Rodón can expect to see in free agency. It is possible, and likely, that Rodón's contract will exceed those terms by a comfortable margin.
Will the Giants be the team to break the bank to keep the hard-throwing lefty? The remains to be seen but they will have the financial flexibility to be aggressive this offseason. However, they did not make an earnest attempt to retain Gausman, so is possible that they will let Rodón walk in the offseason, especially considering that they will have four starting pitchers under contract or team control for next season.
They should absolutely try to keep Rodón, but the front office might be comfortable filling that final rotation spot elsewhere. That could be a bitter pill for fans to swallow if it occurs.