Ever since Robert Murray of FanSided dropped a bomb that the SF Giants are open to trading their ace Logan Webb, everyone has been dropping their own mock trades and ideas. I wrote up a couple earlier today, but one interesting idea could involve the Giants ditching some of their big contracts in a Webb trade.
Michael Montreal of Just Baseball Media, and formerly of Around the Foghorn, posted the following on social media: “We’ve gotten very vague reports up to now, but if teams like the Jays and Braves are in fact calling about Webb, I wonder what a return looks like if you attach Adames and money. I wouldn’t be surprised if Posey tried to get off one of him or Chapman, but will be very difficult.”
This is an interesting thought. If the Giants trade Webb they are essentially admitting they don’t think they can compete in 2027 or 2028 so they might as well just have a full fire sale at that point. They could try to offload one of their bad contracts like the one shortstop Willy Adames is on which owes him over $150 million or Matt Chapman’s which owes him over $100 million.
As Monreal notes, trading either of those guys won’t be easy since they both have a no-trade clause. Plus, if the Giants package Webb with a guy like Webb or Adames then they are probably going to limit the return they could get from a team since they’ll have to take on a big deal that likely won’t age very well.
The Toronto Blue Jays and Atlanta Braves could make an interesting trade partner for a Webb-Adames package since both teams could use a starting pitcher and a shortstop. Plus, Toronto has reportedly kicked around the idea of trading for Adames. The Giants should still be able to get a decent return especially if they decided to take on a bad contract from Atlanta like Spencer Strider or from Toronto like Anthony Santander although that might be a tough sell given Santander’s recent behavior.
Giants may not decide to trade Webb if the price is not right
This is the part of the article where we have to remind everyone a Webb trade is not a certainty. It’s not even likely. But it’s now possible which is why it’s important to take a look at all the different versions of what a Webb trade could look like.
The Giants should have everyone on the table after a brutal 2026 season so that means being open to any and all trades. That doesn’t mean taking pennies on the dollar for all of their players but it does mean they may have to get creative if they want to clear the deck for some of the talent they hope will eventually emerge from the farm system.
