2. George Burns (1911-1921)
Wins Above Replacement: 36.1
Burns played 11 seasons with the Giants. In 1913 and 1914, Burns earned MVP votes, finishing fourth in 1914. That year he had a slashline of .303/.403/.417 for an OPS of .820. That also led to a 6 Win season for Burns. He had another 6 Win season in 1917 as well.
Overall, he played 1,362 career games in left field in New York and had a career slashline with the Giants of .290/.368/.391 for an OPS of .759.